An Oak Grove man was sentenced to 12 years in prison Wednesday for his role in the neglect and eventual death of his father over 14 months ago.
Christian County Circuit Judge Andrew Self handed down the sentence, which comes a month after Gilstrap and his attorney Renae Tuck of Eddyville mediated a guilty plea instead of going to trial.
Gilstrap pled guilty to amended charges of wanton abuse, wanton exploitation of an adult, and eight counts of animal cruelty. He also saw his murder charge amended to reckless homicide.
Gilstrap and his girlfriend Ann Harrison were charged with murder, first-degree criminal abuse, and several other charges in connection to the death of Anthony Gilstrap, Sr. The Oak Grove Police Department investigation said the elder Gilstrap was taken to the hospital on July 10, 2022, and was reportedly unresponsive with signs of severe neglect.
The police investigation also revealed the couple had put themselves as power of attorney over the man’s banking account and removed money from his account as well as started a life insurance policy for him.
Tuck told the court that Gilstrap had already served 13 months in the county jail and felt that punishment would suffice along with a probated sentence for her client.
click to download audioGilstrap told Judge Self he was sorry he didn’t do more to stop the abuse.
click to download audioGilstrap has stated it was Harrison who masterminded the plot to have the elder Gilstrap be neglected and they take over his finances.
Commonwealth’s Attorney Stephanie Bolen said Harrison has declined a mediation offer and wishes to go to trial on her charges.
Judge Self said a trial for Gilstrap removes the chance to learn all of the facts in the case.
click to download audioWhile Judge Self appreciated Gilstrap’s honesty, he still felt a punishment was warranted.
click to download audioHarrison’s attorney Stephanie Ritchie-Mize told the court during her appearance last week she was working to provide financial records that could provide insight into her defense. Harrison remains free on bond while wearing an ankle monitor.
